
Tom Sandoval Takes His Band to AGT 2025 for a Second Chance — and the Judges Have Their Say!
For years, Tom Sandoval has been a familiar face in reality television, but his appearance on America’s Got Talent brought him into a very different spotlight. This time, he wasn’t there simply to talk about his personal life. He arrived with his band, Tom Sandoval and The Most Extras, hoping to show audiences another side of himself: the musician.
Best known for his role on Vanderpump Rules, Sandoval became the center of enormous public criticism following the relationship scandal widely known as “Scandoval.” Now, he was ready to step onto one of America’s biggest talent-show stages and let his music do the talking.
His introduction was certainly memorable. Referring to himself as the “most hated man in America,” Sandoval explained that this was his opportunity to show the judges who he was as a musician.
From Reality TV Controversy to the AGT Stage
Tom Sandoval’s public image had been shaped by years of reality television, particularly his appearances on Vanderpump Rules.
In 2023, his affair with fellow cast member Rachel Leviss became a major entertainment story. The controversy, commonly called “Scandoval,” also ended his long-term relationship with Ariana Madix and brought widespread criticism.
Rather than avoiding the subject entirely, Sandoval acknowledged the reputation that followed him when he introduced himself to the AGT judges.
But his goal was to shift the conversation toward something he had pursued beyond reality television: music.
He arrived with his band, Tom Sandoval and The Most Extras, ready to perform in front of Simon Cowell, Howie Mandel, Sofía Vergara, and Mel B.
For Sandoval, the audition offered an opportunity to be seen in a different role, not just as a reality-TV personality.
Tom Sandoval and The Most Extras Choose an Iconic Song
When it was time to perform, Sandoval and his band selected a familiar classic: “Take On Me” by Norwegian pop group A-ha.
Originally released in the 1980s, the song is known for its recognizable melody and energetic sound. It was an ambitious choice for a talent-show audition, giving the group an opportunity to demonstrate both musical ability and stage presence.
Sandoval took the lead as the band’s frontman, wearing a sparkling emerald-green jacket and moving energetically across the stage.
The performance was not simply about singing the notes. The band brought an entertaining atmosphere, with the musicians supporting Sandoval as he delivered his version of the famous song.
The judges initially appeared skeptical, particularly given Sandoval’s background in reality television. However, as the performance continued, the atmosphere began to change.
Simon Cowell eventually smiled, while the band’s energy and Sandoval’s stage presence helped make the audition an entertaining moment.

Simon Cowell and the Judges React to the Performance
One of the most interesting parts of the audition was watching the judges evaluate Sandoval beyond his television reputation.
Simon Cowell was not completely convinced by the vocal performance, offering criticism of Sandoval’s singing. However, he also recognized the entertainer’s authenticity and showmanship.
The other judges responded positively to the band’s energy and the entertainment they brought to the stage.
Mel B, Sofía Vergara, and Howie Mandel also had their say, and the group’s performance ultimately received a positive outcome.
Despite the initial skepticism, all four judges voted yes, allowing Tom Sandoval and The Most Extras to advance to the next round.
For a contestant who had entered the competition carrying such a controversial public reputation, receiving four yes votes was certainly a significant moment.
A Different Side of Tom Sandoval
The AGT audition was about more than one performance of a well-known song.
Sandoval had spent considerable time in the public eye because of his personal life. On the AGT stage, he wanted viewers to focus on his musical interests and the band he had built.
He later discussed how the experience helped people see him differently. In an interview published in August 2025, Sandoval said that appearing on the show had helped audiences see him doing something he genuinely enjoyed.
That perspective makes the audition especially interesting. Whether viewers were familiar with his reality-TV history or were discovering him for the first time, they were given an opportunity to see him in a different entertainment setting.
Final Thoughts
Tom Sandoval’s America’s Got Talent audition was certainly an unexpected crossover between reality television and a traditional talent competition.
Bringing The Most Extras to the stage, he performed A-ha’s “Take On Me” in front of four well-known judges. Although Simon Cowell had some reservations about his vocals, the band’s energy and stage presence helped the group earn four yes votes.
His past may have made the audition more controversial than an ordinary musical performance, but the result gave Sandoval an opportunity to move forward as a performer.
Love him or criticize him, one thing is clear: Tom Sandoval came to AGT with something to prove, and he left the audition with all four judges saying yes.
Watch Tom Sandoval and The Most Extras perform “Take On Me” on America’s Got Talent below!
Other iconic AGT auditions and singers: America's Got Talent Other iconic BGT auditions and singers: British's Got Talent
